I think that I've found you might always have mistakes in the machine, but you can do it after having a 2 or 5 click. There are various programs that run on OSRS gold that you have to click several times before it will initiate itself. So just do the same concept but run down it a little. Skillers would become prime targets with this program, as it might log people who try to do the identical thing over and over. I am attempting to work out a little additional information and I'll add them when I get them completely worked out. I am attempting to make it even more non-macro friendly. . .lol...
I am thinking that it would work if you just monitored the well know areas were most macroers work, like in draynor. That is the place I usually go and receive willows. I usually find anywhere from 10- 25 macroers ever couple of hours there, just in my own world. All that I'm asking is a program that will monitor the said areas. Additionally, it will have a perfect view into the trees and also will have the ability to record all that hit on the trees and then you're going to be able to find a list of those players, levels in WC and comb. The levels of comb there ought to help weed out many macroers.
Yea this thought isnt for an instant ban, no. The people who are found suspicous will just be placed on a watch that the jagex staff can track more closely. I understand that they have a version of the going, not using the entire tree viewing idea. There are many people who do timber cutting hours and aren't macroers, this notion will just place them on to a watch that will see if they're macroers or only regular players.
The said program will list all players that hit any pine tree and above, largely watching willows. Any player that hits a tree for more than an hours will be recorded. The recorded players list will be sent to the jagex team. The jagex group will then see how long each participant was at every tree, what axe has been used, thier level for combat and WC. Afterward the jagex group will then decide which players have to be watched more carefully.
This app will even take screen shots. The screen shots will probably cause lag to the game so if anybody has any better ideas here post on that. But the whole idea of a screen shot is to identify whether the player is speaking at all. Many Macroers have a script which will enable players to speak with you personally and you'll have a set question or questions that the program will react to. The screen shot will just help check the chat on that player.
Or when Jagex has a means of recording the conversation throughout the world at any particular time. I strongly doubt they do, even when they did, would you envision or buy RuneScape gold simply fathom the notion of just how much space that would take up. Once time has passed this idea can then be computer optimized and ran automatically. I know just like you stated that there will be people that aren't macroing that'll get banned, however you can always appeal that prohibit.